Records from years of official paranormal investigations conducted by the Navajo Rangers may have been lost or become inaccessible following a computer system upgrade, according to retired Ranger Jonathan Redbird Dover.
Dover discussed the potential loss of investigative records during a September 23 interview with Meg Moonbeam and Jens Patteeuw.
“Toward the end, we were averaging about 70 to 80 [paranormal] cases a year, and our cases were locked down in the system so nobody else could access them. Names were kept out of the reports,” Dover said. “I understand that later on they tried to put a new system in, an updated system, and they said that a lot of the information couldn’t be migrated over.”
Dover did not specify how many paranormal case files were affected or whether any records had been permanently destroyed.
“Stan still has some of the original reports. I think I have some in one of my old hard drives that I have, and a whole bunch of pictures that I haven’t seen in 20 years or so.”
“We’re still digging all that stuff out and looking for it.”
The Navajo Rangers’ paranormal investigations began in 2000, following a complaint from a Navajo elder who reported that a Bigfoot had stolen one of her sheep. Two rookie Rangers were sent to investigate the incident, but the woman believed they were laughing at her and complained to the department’s chief ranger.
According to Dover, the complaint prompted a department-wide meeting in which the chief ordered that paranormal reports be investigated professionally and documented. Dover and his partner, Stanley Milford Jr., were subsequently assigned to handle the major cases.
“From now on, these cases will be investigated professionally and reports will be written,” Dover recalled the chief ranger telling the department.
“And then he turned to me and Stan and pointed his finger at us and said, ‘And you two are getting the major cases.’ And we kind of looked at each other like, ‘You’re not kidding me.’ We’re going to be the X-Files for the reservation.”
“We’re going to be evidence-based and let the evidence speak for itself. And so we approached every case as if we’re a criminal investigation,” Dover said of his time working in the department.
Their investigations were featured in a 2022 episode of Netflix’s Unsolved Mysteries titled “Paranormal Rangers.”
Dover also said that the Navajo Rangers are no longer officially investigating paranormal reports, citing budget cuts and changes in departmental leadership.
“After Stan retired, nobody else is doing that. They’ve got a new director and they’re saying no, none of that. So they’ve got their hands full just in their normal job.”
“Just for that period of time, we were effective. We did, I think, a really good job.”
Dover’s full appearance on the podcast is available below.