← All episodes

45:18

DragonKing Dark: Uncontacted Peoples

Member Research

Carl Stern takes on a listener-suggested topic on this episode of Dragon King Dark: uncontacted peoples, and the moral and ethical questions of what should happen if and when outsiders reach them. Carl admits he would not have thought of it himself, but once it was raised, he wondered why he had never covered it.

The first question is the simplest to state and the hardest to answer. Carl notes that uncontacted tribes may lack immunity to common diseases, which can kill a large share of a community after contact. He asks whether today's vaccines would be enough to protect them if a member chose to leave the group.

Carl points to history, including the Spanish encounter with the Arawak in 1492 and European contact with Aboriginal Australians in 1788, as examples of how outside contact went for the people already living there.

Carl also describes an estimate from 2013 of more than 100 uncontacted tribes worldwide, mostly in the forests of South America, Central Africa and New Guinea. Much of what is known about them, he says, comes from brief, sometimes violent encounters with neighboring groups and from aerial footage.

Brazil is where most of these groups are believed to live, and several are being pushed closer to outsiders by logging.

Carl then turns to a harder question: what if a group practices things that modern societies consider wrong? He argues that moral certainty has a history of going badly, citing forced religious conversion and slavery, and asks how future generations might judge today's convictions.

Still, he says, whose standard do you use, and what would these people's own moral code look like if no outside ideas had ever reached them?

Carl also recounts some historical cases. He mentions Ishi, who in 1911 emerged near Oroville, California, after living most of his life outside United States culture, and the Lacandon people of Mexico, first contacted in 1924 and now numbering about 650.

He also mentions an anecdote about a tribe that reportedly built a wooden shrine to an airplane, though he is unsure whether that story has been debunked.

Carl's answer to the central question leans toward leaving these people alone, while admitting the debate is not simple. He invites listeners to write in with stories about specific tribes.

Listen to the full episode to hear Carl wrestle with the moral questions himself.

Today’s show is focused on a great topic suggestion from one of our patrons — The moral and ethical questions of contacting uncontacted peoples. While extremely rare, there are groups of people who have lived very isolated lives away from modern society. What are the ethical and moral questions about what should happen if and when these people are encountered? It’s a more difficult question than you might suspect, and who are these people anyway? Subscribe to access…

Subscriber Content

This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.

After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez

580+ episodes. New ones every week.

Latest member episode: After Dark: The Bigfoot Evidence Skeptics Got Wrong, Government Werewolf Reports, and TJP Ghost Photo Mystery

UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.

$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.

Get full access