Subscriber Content
This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.
Home of the After Dark podcast
Karl Stern looks at the only player death as a result of an NHL game.
Hockey fans know a grim fact that many casual observers never hear: only one NHL player has died as a direct result of an injury suffered in a game.
In this episode of the Dragon King Dark Podcast, host Carl Stern tells the story of Bill Masterton, a 29-year-old center for the Minnesota North Stars, as part of a series on the darkest moments in pop culture history.
Stern admits hockey is not a sport he follows closely. Living in the Deep South, he says, he rarely hears it discussed. Still, he finds it hard to believe that a game played at high speed, with sticks in every hand and pucks flying at incredible velocity, has produced only one such death.
Masterton's career had real promise. A college standout at the University of Denver, he was part of NCAA championship teams in 1960 and 1961. He was the first player to sign with Minnesota, and on October 11, 1967, he scored the first goal in North Stars franchise history.
The fatal play came on January 13, 1968, at the Met Center against the Oakland Seals. Masterton carried the puck up the ice at full speed, and as Seals defenders Larry Kahan and Ron Harris closed in, he was knocked backward and landed on his head. He was not wearing a helmet, as very few NHL players did at that time.
Masterton was rushed to Fairview Southdale Hospital. His wife, Carol, who had been watching from the stands, reached his bedside, as did his parents, who had been listening to the game from their home in Winnipeg. Doctors judged the injury too severe for surgery. About 30 hours after the fall, he died without regaining consciousness.
Ron Harris, one of the players involved, was haunted by the hit for years. "It bothers you the rest of your life," he said. "It wasn't dirty, and it wasn't meant to happen that way." Masterton's family, for their part, reportedly held no animosity toward the players or the game, with his wife calling it a fluke that could have happened to anyone.
Stern also covers a later investigation. According to a 2011 Toronto Star report, Masterton had complained of migraines, and his coach, Wren Blair, had noticed his face looked alarmingly red and wanted him checked by a doctor. Masterton brushed it off. An autopsy found evidence of an earlier blow to the left temple, and a Toronto neurosurgeon concluded he had suffered second impact syndrome.
The helmet debate that followed moved slowly. Blair reportedly frowned on helmets, and one North Star who wore one was traded after the season. The NHL rejected a mandatory helmet rule multiple times, and it was not until the 1979-80 season that helmets became required for new players.
Stern closes by noting that Masterton's name lives on in the Bill Masterton Memorial Trophy, presented since 1968, and in his retired jersey, number 19, which followed the franchise to Dallas. Listen to the full story and decide for yourself how much one quiet man's death changed the game.
This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.
After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez
Latest member episode: After Dark: The Bigfoot Evidence Skeptics Got Wrong, Government Werewolf Reports, and TJP Ghost Photo Mystery
UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.
$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.