← All episodes

41:23

DragonKing Dark: Odd coincidences

Member Research

Host Karl Stern takes a look at two sets of presidential coincidences and asks whether they are fact, fiction, or just fun. The first is a famous list linking Abraham Lincoln and John F. Kennedy. The second is a stranger story about a set of 19th-century books that some readers say predicted Donald Trump.

Stern starts with a lesson in probability. He compares the endless monkeys-and-typewriters thought experiment to a roulette wheel, arguing that a finite number of letters or numbers makes certain patterns show up sooner than people expect. Every spin is independent, so a streak means little on its own.

He also points out that Lincoln and Kennedy were both American presidents, which narrows the field before any comparison begins. Two people chosen from such a small group will share things.

The Lincoln and Kennedy list is one of the best known. Lincoln was elected to Congress in 1846 and Kennedy in 1946. Both were elected president exactly 100 years apart, in 1860 and 1960. Both were shot on a Friday, and each had a secretary who warned him about a trip. Stern notes that Andrew Johnson and Lyndon Johnson both succeeded them.

Other parallels go further. Stern mentions that Lincoln's birthday, February 12, lines up with the founding of the NAACP in 1909, and that Martin Luther King Jr.'s 1963 march spoke from the Lincoln Memorial. Both presidents also lost a brother and a sister before their political careers ended, as the story goes.

The second story centers on Ingersoll Lockwood, who wrote Baron Trump's Marvelous Underground Journey. Stern says a reader sent him a version claiming the book, along with a later one, foresaw Donald Trump, including a character named Don and a Fifth Avenue hotel.

Stern checked the claims against a Snopes investigation, which confirmed the books are real and available on archive.org. It found the connections were exaggerated. "Baron" is a title, not a first name, and "Don" is a Spanish honorific.

The emailed theory also drew in Nikola Tesla, a supposed time machine, an uncle named John Trump, and the online figure John Titor. Stern says these elements have little connection to the books or to each other, and that the theory selects only what fits.

Stern's verdict is that these are fun, if you don't believe too much. Listen to the full episode at whenitwascool.com.

On this week’s DragonKing Dark podcast, host Karl Stern takes a look at a couple of Presidential coincidences and tries to determine if these are fact, fiction, or just fun? We take a look at the supposed connections between Presidents Kennedy and Lincoln, which is one of the most popular stories. We then look at the lesser known — but still strange — story of the Baron Trump books from the 1800s that supposedly have time…

Subscriber Content

This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.

After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez

580+ episodes. New ones every week.

Latest member episode: After Dark: Bigfoot Howls Linked to a Missing Person, Mysterious Trail Cam Footage and More with Chris Barrera

UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.

$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.

Get full access