Subscriber Content
This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.
Home of the After Dark podcast
Carl Stern takes on the Loch Ness Monster, one of the most recognizable monsters of the 1970s pop culture boom, in this episode of Dragon King Dark. Nessie has turned up in a Police song and in Napoleon Dynamite, but Carl argues it may be the least likely of those famous monsters to be real.
His guide is Hidden: The Loch Ness Monster, a 2012 documentary of about 45 minutes that is available on YouTube.
Most people picture the surgeon's photo when they hear Loch Ness Monster. It was published by the Daily Mail on April 21, 1934, and was supposedly taken by London gynecologist Robert Kenneth Wilson, who refused to have his name attached to it. Only two of his four exposures came out clearly, and the first became the famous image.
Carl says the photo's biggest problem is scale. Without a boat, a horizon, or a landmark, there is no way to tell whether an object on the water is three inches long or 300 feet.
To make the point, he describes a night experiment with glow-in-the-dark bracelets tied to black helium balloons, which vanished into the sky above a football field and left no clue to their real size.
According to the documentary, the photo was a hoax built on revenge. Marmaduke Wetherall, a journalist whose employer, the Daily Mail, had ridiculed him after he found footprints that turned out to be fake, allegedly teamed up with others to stage a new sighting. The creature was reportedly a toy submarine bought from Woolworths, with a head made of wood putty.
The hoaxers gave the plates to Wilson, a friend who enjoyed practical jokes.
The story was confirmed in pieces over time. A 1975 Sunday Telegraph article called the photo fake, and a 1999 book, Nessie: The Surgeon's Photograph Exposed, laid out the details. Carl notes that the second photo is so blurry it tells us almost nothing.
The modern legend started earlier, in 1933. Carl walks through an Inverness Courier article from May 2, 1933, by Alex Campbell, which described Aldie McKay's sighting of a whale-like creature rolling in the loch. Later that year, the paper reported George Spicer's account of a long-necked animal crossing a road.
Carl also cites a BBC account placing the earliest legend in the year 565, when St. Columba reportedly encountered a beast in the River Ness.
The most recent chapter comes from science. Researchers from the University of Otago in New Zealand, led by geneticist Neil Gemmell, sampled DNA from the loch's water. They found no evidence of a plesiosaur, sturgeon, shark, or catfish, but they did find a significant amount of eel DNA. Since the data can't show size, the researchers said giant eels could not be ruled out.
Carl's own view is that a hoax doesn't make the idea silly. Large creatures do live in deep lakes and oceans, and that is a fact. Listen to the full episode to hear his fishing stories, his thoughts on giant squid, and the case for why Nessie may have been nothing at all.
This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.
After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez
Latest member episode: After Dark: The Bigfoot Evidence Skeptics Got Wrong, Government Werewolf Reports, and TJP Ghost Photo Mystery
UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.
$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.