← All episodes

58:29

DragonKing Dark: ‘The Devil and Father Amorth’ documentary

Member Research

Carl Stern takes on *The Devil and Father Amorth*, a 2017 documentary directed by William Friedkin, the filmmaker behind the 1973 horror classic *The Exorcist*. The film follows the ninth exorcism of an Italian woman in the village of Venafro, referred to as Cristina, performed by the elderly priest Gabriele Amorth.

Carl found it on Netflix while searching for something to watch, and it fit the dark occult themes he has been exploring lately.

The film premiered at the 74th Venice International Film Festival in August 2017 and opened widely in the United States in April 2018. Critics were not kind. Rotten Tomatoes lists a 44% approval rating from 39 reviews, and Metacritic gives it 46 out of 100. Carl thinks it is better than those reviews suggest, even if its production feels rough.

Friedkin, who is 84 now, set out to find out whether exorcism is real. Carl's main complaint is that the medical segments leaned toward brain surgeons rather than psychiatrists. Still, he notes that most of the doctors who viewed the footage said the symptoms did not resemble any physical condition they had seen.

Carl also shares his own skepticism about psychiatry, drawn from watching family members go through treatment. He is quick to add that he has seen mentally ill people who are truly struggling, and he believes demonic possession is more complicated than either a purely religious or purely dismissive explanation.

According to Carl, one professor quoted in the film argued that denying demonic possession means tearing pages out of the Bible. Carl points out that some Christian traditions reject the idea entirely, including the fundamentalist background he came from, while he himself finds it present in the New Testament.

Carl describes Amorth, who was in his nineties, as a frail man who makes a silly gesture at the devil that struck him as comical. Cristina, whom Carl estimates was in her fifties or sixties, was held down in a chair by family members as she growled and spoke in guttural voices.

Carl saw nothing supernatural in that, noting that people are deceptively strong and that Latin chanting is hypnotic.

The one thing Carl called a skeptical point was the voices, which he felt sounded multitracked and carried an unnatural reverb, though he acknowledges the room itself could explain it.

Amorth, born in 1925 and ordained in 1954, became an official exorcist in 1986 and founded the International Association of Exorcists in 1990. He died in September 2016 at age 91. According to the film, his favorite movie was *The Exorcist*, which he considered substantially correct despite exaggerated special effects.

Carl concludes that everyone in the room was sincere, and that Cristina's experience was likely a behavioral disorder expressed through a religious framework. The film's follow-up confirms the exorcism failed. Carl calls *The Exorcist* a horror film that still holds up, and he invites listeners to watch the documentary and share their own verdict.

The Devil and Father Amorth is a 2017 documentary film directed by William Friedkin showing the ninth exorcism of an Italian woman in the village of Venafro referred to as “Cristina” with this attempt performed by Father Gabriele Amorth. Friedkin was, of course, the director of 1973’s The Exorcist and he wanted to see an actual exorcism, so he finally got to and filmed it for us all to see. So, what did it look…

Subscriber Content

This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.

After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez

580+ episodes. New ones every week.

Latest member episode: After Dark: TJP on the Aswang Legend, A Ghost Photo He Took, and Narrowly Escaping TWA Flight 800

UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.

$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.

Get full access