Subscriber Content
This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.
Home of the After Dark podcast
Karl Stern of WhenItWasCool.com takes on the Baghdad battery, a topic suggested by a Patreon supporter. The artifact is often treated as an out-of-place relic, a piece of technology that seems to belong to a much later era. Karl argues that the real story is more grounded, and more interesting, than that.
The objects are terracotta jars, about five inches tall. Each holds a cylinder of rolled copper sheet, and inside that sits a single iron rod. Bitumen isolates the rod from the copper at the top, and the whole assembly fits snugly into the jar's opening.
Karl notes that the three parts were found together, though he points out that archaeologists often group unrelated objects by assumption.
The dating is murky. Karl cites a range from 150 BC to 650 AD, and he says that a span of roughly 800 years is hard to justify. Some researchers pointed to the Parthian period, but St. John Simpson of the British Museum, according to the episode, said the original excavation was poorly recorded and the evidence for that date is weak.
The pottery style itself matches a later period.
The object was not found in a recent dig. According to the episode, it had already been unearthed and was discovered in a museum. In the 1930s, Wilhelm Koenig, an assistant at the National Museum of Iraq, proposed in a 1938 paper that the jars were galvanic cells used to electroplate gold onto silver. Skeptics reject that idea.
Experiments followed. Karl recounts that Willard Gray, after World War II, got a current from a reconstruction filled with grape juice. A British television program featuring an Egyptologist reportedly produced half a volt and electroplated a silver statuette over two hours.
In 2005, a Mythbusters episode built ten replica jars with lemon juice as the electrolyte. Connected in series, they produced four volts and plated a small token.
Archaeologist Ken Fetter, speaking on that show, noted that no archaeological evidence links the jars together or shows they were used for electroplating. Karl adds that plating from that era has been found to be fire-gilded using mercury, a very dangerous process.
Critics also say the design is poor for a battery. Gas bubbles at the iron-copper junction reduce performance with use, and a single cell produces less than one volt. Karl pushes back on the missing-wires argument, comparing it to losing the charger for an old television. He also says that a lemon can work as a battery too, so the experiments prove feasibility, not use.
Karl is especially critical of the skeptical write-up he read on RationalWiki. He says it offers religious and medicinal explanations for the jars without sourcing, which he sees as a double standard. He also questions whether the scroll-storage idea, tied to rotted papyrus, holds up, and he notes that professor Elizabeth Stone has rejected the battery claim.
Karl's conclusion: the jury is still out. He hopes that someday evidence will show ancient people had a rudimentary grasp of electricity. Listen to the full episode for the complete case file.
This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.
After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez
Latest member episode: After Dark: Bigfoot Howls Linked to a Missing Person, Mysterious Trail Cam Footage and More with Chris Barrera
UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.
$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.