← All episodes

1:23:37

AD 12/20: Rob Brotherton talks why people believe in conspiracy theories, more!

Member Research

Bryan Alvarez is back on After Dark Radio with a guest tailor-made for the season: Rob Brotherton, author of Suspicious Minds: Why We Believe Conspiracy Theories. Brotherton is a former lecturer in psychology at Goldsmiths University of London and the assistant editor of The Skeptic.

This episode is less about whether a given theory is true and more about what goes on inside the believer's head.

Bryan opens with a New York Times story about Florida Atlantic University moving to fire professor James Tracy, who has promoted false theories about the 2012 Sandy Hook shooting. The Posner family, whose six-year-old son Noah was killed, accused Tracy of harassment in a Sun Sentinel op-ed.

Bryan uses the story to frame the conversation, though he says the show will not focus on Sandy Hook.

Brotherton explains that surveys show surprising numbers of people endorse conspiracy theories. Roughly a quarter to half suspect a government role in 9/11, depending on the question. He also discusses David Icke and his claim that reality is a hologram controlled by reptilian Archons, a idea he says draws sold-out arenas.

The conversation turns to confirmation bias. Brotherton argues that everyone accepts evidence that fits existing beliefs and scrutinizes evidence that does not. Bryan offers a Bigfoot example: a wood knock heard in the woods becomes evidence to a hunter, even though the premise that Bigfoot knocks on wood is itself unproven.

Brotherton offers a working definition of conspiracy theory built on six traits, including unusually competent and evil conspirators, unproven claims, and theories that cannot be disproven. He stresses that real conspiracies, such as Watergate, do happen. Bryan points to Roswell, where the government gave four different explanations, as a case where something clearly did happen.

Later, the pair discuss the proportionality bias, the idea that a huge event must have a huge cause. Brotherton describes a study on the clutter of a desk and a sense of control, and another on seeing patterns in static. The show also touches on how conspiracy beliefs can carry real consequences, from vaccine refusal to violence.

Bryan also covers Whale Scout's fundraiser, de-extinction research, and a faceless-woman account from a caller named Stephen. Listen in for the full case file.

After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez is back today with tons to discuss including an interview with Rob Brotherton talking why people believe in conspiracy theories! Also, news and more! A fun show as always so check it out~!

Subscribe to access this episode

Subscriber Content

This content is available to subscribers. Subscribe to keep reading.

After Dark Radio with Bryan Alvarez

580+ episodes. New ones every week.

Latest member episode: After Dark: Bigfoot Howls Linked to a Missing Person, Mysterious Trail Cam Footage and More with Chris Barrera

UFOs, cryptids, ancient sites, disappearances, and the cases that still don't have good explanations. Members get the full archive, every new episode, and the ones that only run here.

$4.99 a month or $49.99 a year. Cancel anytime.

Get full access